Bagel Gift

Phone Icon (516) 514-7774

Buy Delicious Bagels Online

Our bagels toast up perfectly and can be eaten as a simple snack with cream cheese and lox or as a meal when you add your favorite sandwich fillings. Our customized gift packages contain bagels, cream cheese, and lox. Prices include guaranteed overnight delivery by UPS.

I Love Mom Bagels Spelled Out

New York-Style Bagels

We make our bagels the traditional way, boiling them first and then baking them to perfection. Our seeded bagels have seeds on both sides, not just the top. You can choose from the following bagel flavors for your gift packages:

  • Plain
  • Poppy
  • Sesame
  • Cinnamon Raisin
  • Egg
  • Whole Wheat
  • Pumpernickel
  • Everything
  • Rainbow*
*Our Rainbow bagel is a mixture of seven differently colored doughs that we place on top of each other and hand roll to create a tie-dye effect in the bagel.

Whipped Cream Cheese

Everyone loves a bagel with a schmear. That's why our gift packages include Philly cream cheese. Each 8 Oz. container of cream cheese is hand-whipped by us in our Bagelicious store. Our flavors are as follows:

  • Plain
  • Garden Vegetable
  • Pimento Olive
  • Savory Scallion
  • Hearty Walnut Raisin
  • Sweet Strawberry
  • Smokey Lox Spread

Luscious Lox

If you are like us, a bagel isn't complete without some lox. Our bagel gift packages include a quarter pound of either delectable Nova Scotia lox or heavenly belly lox. The Nova Scotia lox is cold smoked, and the belly lox is brined.

Bagel With Cream Cheese and Lox

Shop Now

Having trouble deciding which gift package to send?

Choose a Bagelicious Bagelgift Card and send the card letting the receiver choose which package they would like.

Click Here